Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Case Partners to connect and practice with!

Anonymous A

on Jul 10, 2024

Global

Restating the question/problem statement

Hi there,

- When I hear the prompt of a case I repeat the situation including the question.
- After that I typically ask some clarification questions.
- And as a final step I say somethhing like: ok then we have the problem XYZ - correct? If the interveiwer says yes, then I say, ok let me write it down.
- Then I say can I take a minute to structure the problem.

So what I am essentially doing is to mention the problem statement twice. After summarizing the prompt and after the clarification question before I jump into the structuring. I do that to make sure I am still aligned with the client/interviewer as the clarification questions may lead to a more specific problem statement or a slightly different one compared to the case prompt.

Does that make sense? Or would you recommend not doing it as it could be wired repeating the problem statement twice in a short time?

Cheers

5 Answers

500+ Views

Be the first to answer!

Nobody has responded to this question yet.

Top answer

Ariadna

Coach

on Jul 10, 2024

BCG | Project Leader and Experienced Interviewer | MBA at London Business School

Hey!

To me, this part is off “When I hear the prompt of a case I repeat the situation including the question”. I see no point in in repeating what the interviewer had just said.

You could very briefly summarize what you heard, then proceed with clarifying questions, then time to think about the structure

Directly clarifying questions, then summary with all you heard (again, focus is on summary, not on repeating), then quiet time to structure.

You also do not need to announce you will write it down :) Do that directly, either the first time you hear it (I would recommend this) or at the start of your structuring time.

Hope this helps,

Ariadna

Contact coach

2 comments

Anonymous A

on Jul 10, 2024

Of course, with repeating I mean summarizing the main points :) And if I understand you correctly, you say that I should not mention the problem statement twice resp. directly before I start structuring the case - correct? When should I say the problem statement to align with the interviewer/client?

Ariadna

Coach

on Jul 10, 2024

BCG | Project Leader and Experienced Interviewer | MBA at London Business School

(1) You should restate as part of your summary (that can come before or after the clarifying questions, usually depending on the length of the prompt) E.g., "Ok, let me see if I understood this correctly: the Customer is a product X manufacturer that wants to understand if they should sell to market Y, knowing X and Z. Can I now take 2 minutes to structure my approach?" (2) When you explain your structure, you should re-state the problem to solve and link it to the approach. This is essentially being hypothesis driven. In the above example: "In order to determine if it's a good idea for Customer to sell into market X, we would need to assess 3 areas: is the market attractive, can they be competitive in the market and are the barriers to entry significant". As you can see, the problem to solve is repeated within the approach, you would not say verbatim "the question you asked me is this".

Pedro

Coach

on Jul 11, 2024

Bain | EY-Parthenon | Private Equity | Market Estimates | Fit Interview

You are describing the process, but not what you are trying to achieve with that process… just following the process has no value on itself, but making sure you understand the context (+understand any technical terms), you clearly define the scope (of potential actions) and refine / better define the objective is what you are trying to achieve.

I can't stress enough how important this part of the case interview is… this is where you understand what is really unique about the situation, which is key to then develop a customized approach. So you have to be purposeful when executing this “process”.

Contact coach

Dennis

Coach

on Jul 11, 2024

Roland Berger|Project Manager and Recruiter|7+ years of consulting experience in USA and Europe

Hi there,

your recap of the prompt should be shorter than the time it took the interviewer to give you the prompt. Clarifying questions should be asked to actually clarify whatever might be unclear to you regarding objective and intended scope of the case and/or whatever words/terminology you might not have understood. You want to validate the objective and confirm whether it is the only objective of the case. Then you can ask for some time to write down your thoughts regarding approach and structure.

There is no point in regurgitating what the interviewer already told you - you'd be wasting valuable time.

Hope that helps

Contact coach

Florian

Coach

on Jul 11, 2024

1400 5-star reviews across platforms | 500+ offers | Highest-rated case book on Amazon | Uni lecturer in US, Asia, EU

Hi there,

I would simplify it:

Play back the case
Ask your clarification questions (operationalize the goal + understand the context/business model)
State your intentions to structure the case and ask for time

No need to duplicate efforts or statements.

Cheers,

Florian

Contact coach

Hagen

Coach

on Sep 06, 2024

#1 recommended coach | >95% success rate | most experience in consulting, interviewing, and coaching

Hi there,

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your question:

I see no reason why you should do the third step in the process you described, because if you summarize the prompt and summarize something wrongly, the interviewer will tell you. That's exactly what the summary is for.

You can find more on this topic here: How to succeed in the final interview round.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on how to best prepare for your upcoming interviews, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

Contact coach

Top answer by

Alessa

Coach

xMcKinsey & Company | xBCG | +200 individual & group coachings | feel free to schedule a 15 min intro call for free

6 Answers

1.3k Views

From Intern to Full-Time Consultant: Enhance Communication Skills (4)

In this article, you'll learn how to improve your communication skills from intern to full-time consultant - from active listening to effective conflict resolution.

View article

Interpersonal Communication

Interpersonal communication refers to the exchange of information, thoughts, feelings, and ideas between individuals. It includes both verbal and non-verbal communication and plays a crucial role in interpersonal relationships. This form of communication is fundamental for connection, understanding, and cooperation between people.The following example will show the importance of interpersonal communication: When two friends talk about how their day was, they share not only facts but also emotions and perspectives that can deepen their relationship.Importance in Interpersonal Relationships and RolesInterpersonal communication is essential to build, maintain, and improve relationships. In romantic relationships, it fosters trust and intimacy; in friendships, it enables mutual understanding; and in professional relationships, it improves teamwork and efficiency. In various roles such as parenting, partnership, friendship, and work environments, it enables conflict resolution, information sharing, and the expression of empathy.Specifically, successful interpersonal communication in a professional context can lead team members to work together more effectively by sharing clear expectations and providing constructive feedback.Factors for Successful CommunicationSuccessful interpersonal communication requires active listening to understand the speaker's message. In addition, understanding nonverbal signals such as body language and tone of voice is significant. Choosing the right words and considering the receiver's emotions are also critical. Openness, honesty, and empathy promote a good communication climate.Challenges and DifficultiesDifficulties in interpersonal communication can arise from misunderstandings, cultural differences, unclear messages, or lack of empathy. Communication barriers such as distractions, prejudice and lack of openness can hinder understanding.Checklist for Successful CommunicationListen actively: Show interest and focus on your communication partner.Clear messages: Use clear and precise language to minimize misunderstandings.Show empathy: Put yourself in the other person's shoes to promote understanding.Pay attention to non-verbal signals: Pay attention to body language, facial expressions, and tone of voice.Openness and honesty: Share relevant information and feelings openly.Ask questions: Clarify ambiguities to promote understanding.Give constructive criticism: Give feedback respectfully and constructively.Be patient: give the other person time to express himself.Interpersonal Communication in Management ConsultingIn management consulting, successful interpersonal communication is critical to success. Consultants need to gather clear information from clients in order to understand their needs. At the same time, they must communicate solutions and recommendations clearly and persuasively to gain the trust of clients. Teamwork and the ability to communicate effectively with all parties involved are essential to successfully complete projects and build long-term relationships.

View article