Fit criteria

Question

Do candidates pass/fail fit interviews or are those also scored on a competitive basis?

Answer 1

Hello,

This is an excellent question, and the answer is actually in the middle: you are competing with yourself, but you are actually also competing with others. Let me explain.

During a fit interview, you get a score on 3 to 4 different components (for the PEI interview at McKinsey, at least). For each of them, you receive a score.

If you get a 0s or 1s, you fail. Regardless of the rest of your performance during the case. So here, you are competing with yourself.

But if you get 2s and 3s, it does not necessarily mean you pass. It means you will be considered for comparison with others. And, during that comparison process, your entire performance will be looked at: the scores you got for the case, and the scores you got for the PEI.

This is why the PEI/fit interview is so important during your interview preparation process.

Happy to chat more if helpful!
Thomas

Answer 2

Hi there,

It is indeed pass / fail and no scoring per se. Sometimes though in the decision making process, when ranking candidates the relative “performance" during fit section is also compared.

By performance I of course mean, how good and credible your answers was, how strong of a motivation where you able to show and even how you presented yourself.

So it could come to it that it's a differentiator between you and other candidates.

Hope this helps,

Ariadna

Answer 3

Hi there,

Consulting interviews (case and fit) for most firms and offices are not scored on a competitive basis but individually. You are competing against yourself.

In that sense, it's more of a pass or fail.

Cheers,

Florian

Answer 4

Your scoring is against yourself only. In the interview, and in the job as well. Rarely are these decisions done on a relative or competitive basis. Do not worry.

Answer 5

There is a set of criteria that they look for.

If you're interested in this, I just launched a video course specifically on storytelling for interviews:

Video Course: Master the McKinsey PEI

Best,
Cristian

Answer 6

Passing the fit part is mandatory. I personally turned down McKinsey candidates for not performing in the fit part, despite doing a solid case.

Answer 7

Both.

You pass / fail. And you get scored as well… but of course, what is paramount is the case interview.

Answer 8

I highly doubt that it is the sole reason your friend landed the job at BCG, so I wouldn't overestimate its utility.... (read entire answer)

I highly doubt that it is the sole reason your friend landed the job at BCG, so I wouldn't overestimate its utility. I agree with the reasons other experts have put forward here... (read entire answer)

Answer 9

Thank you emails are always a smart move! Don’t sweat it too much. If the conversation went well, you just have to ho... (read entire answer)

Thank you emails are always a smart move! Don’t sweat it too much. If the conversation went well, you just have to hope your interviewer will show some grace. Your note should h... (read entire answer)

Answer 10

Hi there! Let me take your questions one by one: 1. Do I have to list the second job on my resume even though it was... (read entire answer)

Hi there! Let me take your questions one by one: 1. Do I have to list the second job on my resume even though it was extremely short? (< 3 months) No, you do not have to. If... (read entire answer)