Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Back to overview

Will I make it to Round 2?

McKinsey R1. First interview I was a bit nervous and while trying to structure the math, I was given the answers by the Interviewer and walked through it. I finished the case keeping my composure.

Second interview was great and no nerves were there. Strong all the way through. I'm worried I may have screwed up in the first interview though. Will the performance in my second interview help make a case for me to move forward?

7 Answers
300+ Views
21
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Hagen
Coach
edited on Jan 13, 2025
#1 recommended coach | >95% success rate | most experience in consulting, interviewing and coaching

Hi there,

First of all, congratulations on the progress in the application process with McKinsey thus far!

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your question:

  • First of all, no one can seriously answer the question of whether or not you will make it to the final interview round. Only you and your interviewers have experienced your performance, so unfortunately you'll have to wait and see.
  • Moreover, I would highly advise you to apply to other consulting firms, if you haven't already, to maximize your chances of getting at least one offer.

You can find more on this topic here:ย How to succeed in the final interview round.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on how to best prepare for your upcoming McKinsey interviews, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

Mattijs
Coach
on Jan 12, 2025
Free 15m intro call | First session -50% | Bain Consultant | Hiring team | 250+ successful candidates

Hi,ย 

While there are no guarantees, having the interviewer assist you during a case interview isn't necessarily a disqualifier. Interviewers may sometimes provide hints or guidance to evaluate how well you can build on their input and adjust your approach. What's most important is how you respond to the assistance: demonstrate your problem-solving skills, clear communication, logical thinking, and ability to integrate feedback. They are also considering if you demonstrate qualities that align with the firm's values and culture?

Just remember to review and practice for future rounds to refine your skills further. Happy to assisst during a personal coaching session. Good luck!

Mattijs

on Jan 12, 2025
Ex-BCG Project Leader | Experienced Interviewer | Free 20min Intro Call

Impossible to give you a definitive answer, but donโ€™t take the interviewerโ€™s action as a statement that youโ€™re done/didnโ€™t pass. They couldโ€™ve noticed you clearly struggled and threw you a freebie.ย 

Itโ€™s not ideal to completely miss the mark on an important analysis on the case. ย You ability to move forward really depends on how strongly the other case went and how well you recovered from that pointโ€ฆย 

  • Did you act gracefully, take the results, and continued to drive towards insights and additional analysis needed?
  • Did you ask thoughtful follow ups and arrive at the implications of the analysis to the customer? ย 
Mariana
Coach
on Jan 12, 2025
You CAN make it! | xMckinsey | 1.5h session | +200 sessions |Free 15-Minute Call

Hello there!

Being in this position is tough, I know. Unfortunately, itโ€™s difficult to determine if your performance in one interview will impact your chances after a strong second interview. However, based on both rounds, you may still be given the opportunity to advance to a third round or even pass through to the final stage. Ultimately, it depends on how significant the mistakes were, how well you performed in the second and the interviewersโ€™ perspectives. In my experience, interviewers might let small mistakes slide if the case was overall well done, but this varies depending on the severity of the error and their own evaluation. It was a good thing you kept your posture, an interview is a mock of a conversation between you and your manager/partner or a client โ€” sometimes consultants make mistakes and have to still convey trust, so well done on that.
Structuring the math was also a challenge for me once, until I internalized a fool-proof approach. Let me know if I can assist you with thatโ€”Iโ€™d be happy to help.ย 
Wishing you the best of luck in your interview process and keeping my fingers crossed for you!

Best, ย 
Mari

Thabang
Coach
on Jan 12, 2025
Ex-McKinsey Consultant | McKinsey Top Coach & Interviewer | Special Offer: Buy 1 Session Get 1 Free (Limited time!)

Hey there,ย 

It's not really possible for anyone to tell you if you will move forward as we can't really ascertain the true level of your two performances. But I will share some general principles on this

For you to move forward to the next round, generally the two interviewers need to both agree and give you a pass. If your performance in one didn't meet the bar whilst the other did, then generally that tends to mean the end of the journey. However, it is possible (in this example) to get a 3rd interview if they feel that you have potential and are not able to distinctively make a yes or no recommendation on your case

So the extent to which one interviewer influences the other really depends on how well and how not-so-well you did in each interview

Regardless, wishing you all the best

Georges
Coach
on Jan 13, 2025
Ex Senior Manager and Recruiting Team at Bain | 8+ Years MBB Experience | 90%+ offer success rate| Middle East Expert

Hi there,

First off, well done on keeping your composure and finishing both interviewsโ€”thatโ€™s already a win! Let me share some insights that might help ease your worries:

How McKinsey Evaluates R1 Interviews

  • McKinsey looks at overall performance across both interviews, not just one. A strong performance in your second interview can absolutely make up for a weaker first one.
  • Interviewers often align afterward to assess whether you demonstrated the skills theyโ€™re looking for: problem-solving, communication, and composure under pressure. Finishing strong in the second interview works in your favor.

About Your First Interview

Itโ€™s okay to have moments where the interviewer steps in to guideโ€”this happens more often than you think. What matters is how you responded:

  • Did you stay composed and follow their lead?
  • Did you recover and finish the case with clear thinking?

If you did, the interviewer may see this as resilience rather than a weakness.

What Happens Next?

Youโ€™re being evaluated holistically, and many candidates have moved forward with a similar experience. Keep a positive mindsetโ€”itโ€™s not uncommon for one โ€œokayโ€ interview to be balanced by a strong second one.

Feel free to reach out if you want advice on preparing for Round 2โ€”fingers crossed for you!

Ian
Coach
on Jan 13, 2025
#1 BCG coach | MBB | Tier 2 | Digital, Tech, Platinion | 100% personal success rate (8/8) | 95% candidate success rate

We don't know. You'll find out when you find out.

That said, never hinge on 1 company (if you can help it).

Always, always, always, keep recruiting until you have an offer in hand.

Similar Questions
Consulting
Does McKinsey Give Offers Prior to Competition of All Interviews?
on Jan 15, 2025
USA
4 Answers
200+ Views
Top answer by
Thabang
Coach
Ex-McKinsey Consultant | McKinsey Top Coach & Interviewer | Special Offer: Buy 1 Session Get 1 Free (Limited time!)
11
4 Answers
200+ Views
+1
Consulting
PWC Interview Timeline/Process
on Jan 27, 2025
USA
6 Answers
900+ Views
Top answer by
Hagen
Coach
#1 recommended coach | >95% success rate | most experience in consulting, interviewing and coaching
49
6 Answers
900+ Views
+3
Consulting
How Many Interviews To Expect For McKinsey Associate Position in USA?
on Jan 31, 2025
USA
3 Answers
300+ Views
Top answer by
Florian
Coach
1400 5-star reviews across platforms | 600+ offers | Highest-rated case book on Amazon | Uni lecturer in US, Asia, EU
22
3 Answers
300+ Views
How likely are you to recommend us to a friend or fellow student?
0 = Not likely
10 = Very likely
You are a true consultant! Thank you for consulting us on how to make PrepLounge even better!