Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Case Partners to connect and practice with!
Back to overview

Redrock Study percentage questions

Hi,

I have recently bought the Mconsultingprep package for McKinsey Solve. The explanations for the Redrock Study are very detailed. 

However, would anyone be able to let me know why the methods are different. I interpret the questions as asking for the same thing but the answers given and way they have been derived seem to differ from one game to the next, especially for percentage differences.

Game 1

Q- What is the percentage difference between estimated hunts with relocation and the target hunts?

A- (Estimated hunts with relocation - Target)/ ((Estimated hunts with relocation + Target) / 2)) *100

Game 2

Q- What is the difference in percent between the average travel time from repopulation and the target for average travel time?

A- (Estimated average travel time from repopulation - Target) /Target *100

Game 3

Q- What is the percentage difference between the percentage increase in avg energy consumption in room A and that of the hotel?

A- (Percentage increase in room A - Percentage increase in Hotel)/ Percentage increase in Hotel * 100

 

Please could you tell me why these methods are different and what hint in the question I am missing?

 

Thank you!

2 Answers
< 100 Views
14
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Hagen
Coach
edited on Oct 14, 2024
#1 recommended coach | >95% success rate | most experience in consulting, interviewing, and coaching

Hi there,

First of all, congratulations on the (presumed) invitation from McKinsey!

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your question:

  • First of all, although you may not want to hear this, the percentage questions in MConsultingPrep's McKinsey Solve package seem to be significantly over-engineered. In the actual Redrock Study part of the McKinsey Solve pre-interview assessment, it is typically displayed how to calculate and display the results.
  • Moreover, the displayed answers do not always calculate what is required. In question one, the formula should be the absolute value of (“estimated hunts” / ”target hunts”) – 1. In question two, the formula is correct, which can be simplified to the absolute value of (“average travel time from repopulation” / ”target for average travel time”) – 1. In question three, the formula should be the absolute value of “percentage increase in avg energy consumption in room A” – “percentage increase in avg energy consumption of the hotel”.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on how to best prepare for your upcoming McKinsey Solve pre-interview assessment and McKinsey interviews, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

Alessa
Coach
on Oct 13, 2024
xMcKinsey & Company | xBCG | feel free to schedule a 15 min intro call for free

Hey there!

The differences in methods for calculating percentage differences across the various McKinsey Solve games stem from the specific contexts and types of comparisons being made in each question. For Game 1, the method uses the average of the two values (estimated hunts with relocation and target) in the denominator. This is appropriate when trying to understand the percentage difference relative to an average, helping normalize the difference, especially when the values can vary significantly.

In Game 2, the formula compares the estimated average travel time directly against the target, using the target as the denominator. This emphasizes how far the estimated time deviates from the target, which is a common method for evaluating performance against a goal.

Game 3 uses a similar approach but focuses on the relative difference compared to a baseline, in this case, the hotel’s percentage increase. This method provides insight into how room A's increase compares to a standard benchmark, making it useful for performance assessments.

Overall, context matters greatly in these calculations. Each formula is derived based on the specifics of the question and what you’re trying to assess, whether it's a comparative performance against an average, a target, or another baseline. The choice of denominator significantly affects how to interpret the percentage difference, so it's crucial to analyze the question carefully to determine which figure represents the best baseline for comparison.

Hope this helps! 

Alessa

Similar Questions
Consulting
Stuck at Math/Quantitative and What to Calculate in Consulting Cases
on Jan 15, 2024
Global
7 Answers
800+ Views
Top answer by
LK
Coach
50% off
22
7 Answers
800+ Views
+4
Consulting
Timing for math portion of case
on Mar 31, 2024
Global
5 Answers
500+ Views
Top answer by
Brad
Coach
Expert coach | Head of recruiting for Bain | 8+ years interviewing | Free intro call
10
5 Answers
500+ Views
+2
Consulting
Structuring & qualitative/quantiative part of case
on Aug 23, 2024
Global
5 Answers
500+ Views
Top answer by
Anonymous
Top Performer: From Science to working for BCG's C-suite
33
5 Answers
500+ Views
+2
How likely are you to recommend us to a friend or fellow student?
0 = Not likely
10 = Very likely
You are a true consultant! Thank you for consulting us on how to make PrepLounge even better!