Possible error on figure 4?

Question

On figure 4 of this question, we are told that the fixed costs are $ per plane per year:

The startup must pay satellite operators an annual satellite fee. (50K)
In addition, the startup must pay the operator for every megabyte downloaded in-flight. (0.1 / MB)
The airline charges a yearly licensing fee. (75K)
The investment costs include amortized acquisition and installation costs. (25K)

We calculate that the total fixed costs are 50K + 75K + 25K = 150K.

However, in the solution, we are told to find the fixed cost per plane to be 150K / 600 (where 600 is the number of planes in its fleet) = $250 per plane.

Is this not a contradiction? To me, this shows that the metric in table 4 is NOT per plane per year.

Answer 1

Dear,

Thanks for the question. After reviewing the case, I believe the confusion can be clarified as follows:

The total fixed costs per plane are $150,000
When we break down these fixed costs on a per-flight basis, it amounts to $250 per flight ($150,000/600).

The case instructions state that each plane completes 600 flights over the years, indicating that they operate more than once per year, which is a reasonable assumption.

Therefore, it is essential to determine whether you intend to conduct the break-even analysis on a per-flight or per-plane basis. The solution provided in the case follows the former approach, focusing on calculating the required number of customers for each flight.

This involves:

Calculating the fixed cost per flight, which is $250, as demonstrated earlier
Assuming an average data consumption of 100 MB per customer per flighy
Assuming that the revenue per customer on each flight remains constant at $15.

I hope this clarification addresses any concerns. I think it's only a matter of understanding that “flight” is a different concept of “plane”.

If you have any further questions or require additional clarification, please do not hesitate to reach out to me via direct message.

Best,

Antonio

Answer 2

Hi there!

I see Antonio already gave you a great answer. If you have any follow-ups, let us know.

Aside from this, here are a few other cases to look into:

https://www.preplounge.com/en/management-consulting-cases/interviewer-led-mckinsey-style/intermediate/mbb-second-round-codewave-employee-turnover-challenge-304

https://www.preplounge.com/en/management-consulting-cases/candidate-led-usual-style/advanced/mbb-first-round-soy-technologies-303

https://www.preplounge.com/en/management-consulting-cases/interviewer-led-mckinsey-style/intermediate/element-mobile-expands-into-refurbished-phones-mbb-2nd-round-302

Best,
Cristian

Answer 3

The main difference really is the risk at stake. Entrepreneurial Drive is more about having initiative and driving th... (read entire answer)

The main difference really is the risk at stake. Entrepreneurial Drive is more about having initiative and driving things forward, but Courageous Change is about making the hard... (read entire answer)